Pages

Saturday, September 8, 2012

ASI: A Method for Planning Lessons


The lessons at ASI were all planned using Charlotte Mason's own techniques.  In Home Education, she describes her method of lesson planning:

"In every case the reading should be consecutive from a well-chosen book.  Before the reading for the day begins, the teacher should talk a little (and get the children to talk) about the last lesson, with a few words about what is to be read, in order that the children may be animated by expectation; but she should beware of explanation and, especially, of forestalling the narrative.  Then, she may read two or three pages, enough to include an episode; after that, let her call upon the children to narrate--in turns, if there be several of them.  They not only narrate with spirit and accuracy, but succeed in catching the style of their author.  It is not wise to tease them with corrections; they may begin with an endless chain of "ands," but they soon leave this off, and their narrations become good enough in style and composition to be put in a  "print book"!

This sort of narration lesson should not occupy more than a quarter of an hour.  The book should always be deeply interesting, and when the narration is over, there should be a little talk in which moral points are brought out, pictures shown to illustrate the lesson, or diagrams drawn on the blackboard.  As soon as children are able to read with ease and fluency, they read their own lesson, either aloud or silently, with a view to narration...

Let us consider each of the key points of Charlotte Mason's thoughts as delineated in this selection.

A well-chosen book


It is the task of the teacher to select the text.  Although we did not specifically discuss this idea, we were exposed to the selection of books that Ambleside has chosen and has deemed "well-chosen".  What I particularly noted was that it is not necessary for a book to be a historical novel in order to be a "living book". Several of the books fell into the category of textbook, but were written in a more engaging and interesting style than the standard fare.  So, for example, the history book was one written by Dorothy Mills, a non-fiction work that is a textbook but reads like an engaging documentary.  Similarly, the science text was a volume that had different authors write on their respective areas of expertise.  

When choosing a text, whether fiction or non-fiction, one might ask themselves, "Is this true or true-to-life?  That is, is the information contained in it correct? Does it illustrate the consequences of moral choices and action in a way that reflects accurately the ultimate consequences of our choices?  Is good eventually rewarded or shown to be noble and worthy?  Is evil shown to lead to misery and unhappiness?  Is it good or noble? Will it help the student learn why and how to choose the good and noble? Is it beautiful?  Beautifully written? Does it cause the student to appreciate beauty or wonder at the works of our great Creator?

Having chosen the books, then the instructor must plan how the students will engage with them.


Thinking about focusing on habits

First of all, each lesson will focus on one habit or area of character growth.  Paying attention, listening respectfully, taking turns are all general habits that need constant work to develop.  You might also want to focus on more specific habits--using the author's own words in narrations, getting letters to sit on the line, observing punctuation marks.  Tell the student what you are focusing on at the start of the lesson:  "Today, let's be careful to write our letters so that they sit on the line."  At the end of the lesson, return to this point:  "Look over your writing to see if your letters are sitting on the line."


Once you know what habits you will focus on, you can begin to plan.  Their--sheesh!  THERE--- are five main parts to every lesson.  

1.  The First Little Talk

"...the teacher should talk a little (and get the children to talk) about the last lesson, with a few words about what is to be read, in order that the children may be animated by expectation; but she should beware of explanation and, especially, of forestalling the narrative."

     The first little talk is a very short introduction to the day's material. Begin with a brief review of the previous day's material.  Then, you may introduce the current day's work by identifying locations on a map or briefly explaining new vocabulary words and unfamiliar ideas. During this time, the teacher can also provide a structure to help the student(s) mentally organize the material they are about to read, if that would be helpful.  For example, if a science text will be discussing four main parts of a tree, you could write on a board the title "Main Parts of a Tree" and follow it with four bullet points.  Tell the student(s) that he will be reading about the four parts of a tree and should pay particular attention to what they are. Later, during the final discussion, you can fill in the bullet points.  

For a lesson on Joshua, Chapter 2, I had the students turn to a historical map of the Middle EastWe located Jericho, Abel-Shittim, and the Plains of Moab.  Our map was a topographical map, so we also noted that Jericho lies at the base of a very hilly area.  Our vocabulary words included harlot (which I simply defined as a wicked woman, and left it at that!), lodged, and flax. I briefly explained that flax was a kind of grain, similar to wheat, that was used to make linen cloth.  I also explained that homes in the ancient Near East had flat roofs.  The entire introduction took about 5 minutes, including getting out the maps, finding the page we needed, and putting them away.

The hardest part of this first point is keeping it short.  You are not trying to instruct the child in everything you know about the topic.  You just want to shed a bit of light on anything in the text that might be confusing or unfamiliar, and you want to orient the student(s) and connect the new material with what has gone before it.  It is REALLY EASY to let this take over the time you have for engagement with the text.  I am having to be very vigilant so that doesn't happen. 

2.  Reading the text

"Then, she may read two or three pages, enough to include an episode;...  As soon as children are able to read with ease and fluency, they read their own lesson, either aloud or silently, with a view to narration..."

Or observe the picture, listen to the musical piece, study the leaf,  etc.  The next step is to find out what the author/artist/Creator is communicating through the "text".  We want to encourage attention to the actual content of the text.   If narration is new to you, only read a short selection before narrating.  Half a page at most, or even a paragraph or a section of a paragraph (if the material is very dense, such as might happen in a history or science book) would allow a student unfamiliar to narration to be successful.  If you are reading a story or historical novel, try to separate the readings at natural points if you can, such as the end of one incident or the end of one major part of an incident.  You want the breaks to make a bit of sense.

Note that older students should be reading the text aloud or silently to themselves.  It is good to use both techniques.  The oral reading periods are excellent opportunities to assess reading, to coach the student in clear reading and in observing punctuation marks, and to encourage dramatic reading when fictional works are being studied.

We are doing a lot of oral reading right now.  The children take turns reading a section, then we narrate that section.  Occasionally, I read a section to demonstrate good reading skills.  As one child reads aloud, the others follow along in their own books.

Two techniques to help readers who are having difficulty:

--echo reading:  teacher reads, student echos
--choral reading:  everyone reads aloud together, or teacher and student read aloud together


3.  Narrating the text

"...after that, let her call upon the children to narrate--in turns, if there be several of them.  They not only narrate with spirit and accuracy, but succeed in catching the style of their author.  It is not wise to tease them with corrections; they may begin with an endless chain of "ands," but they soon leave this off, and their narrations become good enough in style and composition to be put in a  "print book"!"

Narration is the retelling of the material or ideas that the author presented.  In narration, we are learning to listen to others and respect them.  We are not trying to correct the author or debate with the author.  We are not expressing our own opinions about whatever the author is communicating.  We are just trying to hear and repeat what the author is, in fact, trying to say.  It helps me to think of St. Thomas Aquinas and how he always stated his opponent's point of view before he gave a response to it.  So it is with narration.  We want the student to tell as much as possible about what the author actually said. 

After the text is read, narration can begin with a question or statement.  The question should be open, not a yes or no question.  However, with younger narrators, you may ask a question about part of the text to help them focus their minds.  So, rather than a general, "Tell me what you remember," you might want to try a more specific prompt, such as, "Tell me what you remember about the attack of the Huns on the Visigoths." or "What caused the Huns to attack the Goths?"   To get a reluctant narrator started, it can be helpful to read the opening sentence of the section you just read.  Also, you can choose a sentence in the middle of the selection, and ask them to tell you about that.  

Multiple children can all narrate the same text.  Each one might give a full narration, or they might just add a few points to someone else's narration.  Either is fine.  I have told my children that it is OK for them to give a complete narration, even if their sibling already did so, because each person has a different idea about what they have read and how to tell about it.  This seems to make perfect sense to them.  It is interesting to hear how each individual approaches the task of narrating the same material.

Narration might be written, oral, bullet points, drawn, told to a partner, or silently to oneself. I know some like the idea of narrating into a recording device, but I think narration is an exchange of ideas that requires persons for its effectiveness (even if the person "listening" is just ourselves or if it is someone who will later read our work).  It seems to me that there is too much "distance" between the narrator and the listener with recording devices.  Another post for another day....

4.  Second Little Talk (idea)

"The book should always be deeply interesting, and when the narration is over, there should be a little talk in which moral points are brought out, pictures shown to illustrate the lesson, or diagrams drawn on the blackboard. "

At Ambleside, the second talk focuses on an "inspiring idea".  This is the time during the lesson that children have a chance to think and discuss the deeper ideas present in the material, or to organize the material in helpful ways.  Usually, this talk will begin with a good discussion-starter question.  The question should be one that really draws the students to ponder, as often as possible.  So, when reading and narrating a Bible story, one can ask, "What does this tell us about God?  About people?" In history, one might query, "What factors brought the Middle Ages to a close?" or "What do you learn from this passage about the character of {whomever}?"
In The Door in the Wall,  an episode relates how Brother Luke, a monk, comes to care for the main character, Robin, a crippled boy.  The second talk question I used for that reading was, "What do you learn about compassion from the way Brother Luke treated Robin?"  It is amazing to listen to the  profound thoughts the children express.
 

5.  A word on lesson length

Although Charlotte Mason recommends only quarter hour lessons in Home Education, it is well to remember that that volume dealt with younger children (under 9).  As children mature, they are able to attend for longer periods of time.  In the Ambleside schedules, the fifth grade students have some subjects that last 30 or 45 minutes.  So, I have scheduled 35 minutes for Literature, Science, History, and Math.  Truthfully, I find 15 minutes to be way too short for some of these subjects as the children mature.  Other subjects remain short and sweet--Poetry, Latin, Composer and Picture Study, Memory Work, Copywork, Dictation, etc.  

 

3 comments:

  1. Now this is the part that makes me envy classroom teachers... I would love to be able to do this, but I struggle with being able to prepare to that level consistently. It is also so challenging to make that work with a little one underfoot! But I can see the benefit of it, and we do most of it... The main part I am missing is the little talk and set-up before the reading. It all tends to happen on the fly as needed - and I admit I don't read everything beforehand either. I generally have read it, but it might have been months ago and isn't exactly fresh in my mind.

    I appreciate you sharing this, it certainly gives me something to think about and good ideas for my own improvement in the future!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, I think I noted before that I don't think I could have done this with little ones around. However, I am thinking about how it might be adjusted to accommodate a family with little ones. I hope to post my musings...
    Hang in there! I know how crazy it can be with babies/toddlers...I did it for 20+ years!!! And most of it was definitely done "on the fly"! I so admire you for being able to do all you do!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Caroline, it took me a few days to get through this post - I kept coming back! - but I wanted to let you know how helpful it was. I am trying not to be jealous of your opportunity to learn at an Ambleside School. We have one about an hour and a bit away in Fredricksburg, TX but I can't see a time in the near future that I could afford the time or the cost. So I am so happy you are sharing. The hardest thing is really the preparation, I think! To read ahead, and know exactly what you will be reading each day so that you can give the little talk.. I've been trying to read When Children Love to learn as I never finished it the last time I was reading it, and MaryEllen St. Cyr is a contributor. I , too, have a baby/toddler and preschoolers like Amber, and it is challenging. I'd love to hear your ideas for adjusting to accommodate a younger family. I've thought of keeping my 6 year old and 8 year old together for more subjects but they are on such different read and discussion levels in so many areas! Anyway, thank you for the visuals and discussion!

    ReplyDelete